The Puck Newsletter
November 2023

   
To Our Puck Community –
 
Over the past few years, you have listened and read as we have tried our best to cover the current state of our world through conversations. At first there were just VCs, and now we have authors, scientists, media entrepreneurs, religious scholars, and are about to do a series on the current state of Mental Health in our country.
 
Some of you come here from the business community at large, others through CMBG, and others still through our Puck Podcast. As I have said   many times before, the issue at the heart of our mission here is bridging the rising trend of polarization. I see too few people speaking with one another, too few listening, too few actually engaging in having difficult discussions. And, if people aren’t capable of even having challenging conversations, how in the world are they going to agree on a collective course of action when looking at the world from such vastly different points of view.
 
In my mind, the first step is the one we too often ignore. Having difficult conversations. Actually engaging the only way we all know: talking to people within our immediate circles, within our communities, as strange and as uncomfortable as that might be. And listening when they have something to say back. Genuinely admitting when we don’t have all the answers, and looking for reading recommendations when we are legitimately willing to learn, beyond the memes and info graphs and soundbites that have dominated our media landscape for the past three weeks.
 
This newsletter is by no means meant as a substitute for the real experts – those who have made careers in diplomacy and journalism and academia studying the Middle East. But, I’d like to try my best to practice what I preach. If the aim is beginning to have difficult conversations in order to ultimately tackle polarization, then this might be a start.
 
A Call for Global Unity
 
In a recent statement shared on Twitter, former President Barack Obama expressed his thoughts on the current crisis and emphasized the need for collective action to address the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. As a Jew, I cannot help but reflect on the historical atrocities committed against my people during the Holocaust, which ultimately led to an overwhelming moment of geopolitical consensus which established the state of Israel. However, it is crucial to recognize that the ongoing challenges with the Palestinians require a collaborative effort from the international community. Together, we can work towards a resolution that benefits not only the Jewish people but also all of humanity.
 
The Holocaust and the Birth of Israel
 
The Holocaust remains a somber reminder of the depths of human cruelty and the urgent need for a safe haven for the Jewish people. The collective guilt felt by the world for not doing enough to prevent the slaughter led to the establishment of the state of Israel. This historical context underscores the importance of acknowledging the Jewish people's right to self-determination and security.
 
Examining the years leading up to the Nazi's Final Solution, it is essential to recognize that many Jews attempted to immigrate to Israel, which was then under British administration. However, resistance from the Palestinian population in the region, combined with British restrictions on immigration, complicated the situation. The Allies' post-war realization of the horrors endured by the Jewish people in concentration camps spurred collective guilt and momentum to establish a homeland for them. In 1948, the United Nations divided the disputed region into two areas. While Israel accepted the partition plan, the Palestinians and Arab nations rejected it, leading to a war that resulted in the displacement of many Palestinians. Everyone from former Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice to Crooked Media’s Pod Save the World has weighed in on the history here. Wherever you align politically, I’d still recommend, you go find a variety of experts.
 
The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
Despite the establishment of Israel, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has persisted, causing immense suffering for both sides. This is a complex issue with deep-rooted historical, political, and religious dimensions. The conflict has caused profound pain and loss for both Israelis and Palestinians, emphasizing the need to approach it with empathy and a commitment to finding a just and lasting solution.
 
The Need for Global Cooperation
Addressing the Israeli-Palestinian conflict necessitates the active involvement of the international community. By collaborating, nations can contribute to fostering dialogue, promoting understanding, and facilitating negotiations between the parties involved. It is essential to recognize that this conflict is not solely a Jewish or Palestinian problem but a global issue that affects the entire world.
 
This complexity is compounded when countries, like Iran, led by fundamentalists bent on the destruction of the Jewish state and the expulsion of Christians from the Middle East, continue to fund terrorists. How can we make peace with a majority of the Palestinian people when fundamentalist Palestinians receive funding and training to perpetuate violence against the Jewish people?
 
One significant challenge is the "right of return" and the use of the Palestinian people as pawns historically by other Arab nations. It is not coincidental that countries like Jordan have not granted citizenship to Palestinians residing within their borders. Many fundamentalists who oppose women's and LGBTQ+ rights aim to eradicate Israel and end Christianity as well.
 
Vox Media has been doing some really excellent reporting and providing context. And yet, underscoring how difficult this all is, Jonathan Guyer, a Vox foreign policy writer, recently omitted key terms like "right of return" and "refugees" in his article on "How the Arab world sees the Israel-Palestine conflict." This omission is notable, considering the significant role these concepts play in the conflict, affecting the Two-State Solution and Israeli politics. Some argue that the right of return derailed  the Camp David talks and the creation of an independent Palestine, while others disagree.
 
Guyer acknowledges Arab support for Palestinian rights but criticizes the Biden administration for not considering this in its approach. Arab governments may have interests in dealing with Israel, but their populations often oppose this, making it crucial to understand the domestic politics of the Arab world.
 
The conflict's origin in 1948, involving the displacement of Palestinians, remains a point of contention between Zionist and Palestinian narratives. The right of return, as advocated by Palestinians, involves refugees and their descendants returning to their pre-Nakba homes in Israel. This has demographic implications for Israel, leading to debates on the Two-State Solution.
 
It's vital to differentiate between advocating for the Palestinian cause (reversing the Nakba) and the welfare of the Palestinian people. Pro-Palestinian advocacy focuses on the former, often resulting in limited improvements in the lives of stateless Palestinian refugees.
 
Promoting Peace and Humanity
 
Resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict would bring relief to the affected populations and serve as a testament to the power of collaboration and diplomacy. By working towards a just and peaceful resolution, we can restore faith in humanity's ability to overcome deep-seated divisions and promote coexistence. This endeavor would not only benefit the Jewish people but also contribute to the overall well-being of humanity.
 

WE CAN ALWAYS DO MORE

 

This month The Puck is highlighting GlobalGiving, a nonprofit that helps fellow nonprofits thrive. Their mission is to transform aid and philanthropy to accelerate community-led change. GlobalGiving makes it possible to support local projects in 175+ countries, while giving nonprofits access to the funding, tools and training they need to serve their communities. When disasters strike, GlobalGiving quickly delivers funds to community-led organization that are best-suited to provide relief and long-term recovery.
 
GlobalGiving is a 501 © (3) organization, and donations are tax-deductible.